Doctor-led aesthetics in Sutton Coldfield
MDr MaryamAesthetics

Profhilo

Profhilo with subcision for acne scars: what did the 12-person trial show?

A small split-face trial found higher satisfaction when Profhilo was added to subcision, but no significant advantage in objective scar reduction or ultrasound-measured scar depth.

5 minute read

Atrophic acne scars are not all the same

Atrophic acne scars sit below the surrounding skin and are commonly described as rolling, boxcar or ice-pick scars. Their shape, depth and attachment to deeper tissue influence which treatment may help. Subcision is designed to release fibrous attachments beneath selected depressed scars, so it is not a universal treatment for every scar or patch of post-acne pigmentation.

Profhilo is an injectable hybrid hyaluronic-acid treatment used for aspects of skin quality. Adding it to a scar procedure does not make it a replacement for accurate scar classification. Active acne should be controlled first, and a changing, painful or raised lesion needs appropriate diagnosis rather than being assumed to be an ordinary acne scar.

How was the combination studied?

A single-blind, randomised split-face trial enrolled 12 people aged 18 to 45 with atrophic acne scars on both sides of the face. Each participant had subcision on both sides. One randomly assigned side also received 1 ml of Profhilo. Two sessions were performed one month apart, with assessment three months after the final session.

Researchers used photographs assessed by two blinded observers, an ultrasound measurement of scar depth, a global improvement scale and patient satisfaction. A split-face design helps control for differences between individuals, but both sides received an active procedure. The trial therefore examined whether Profhilo added benefit to subcision; it did not test Profhilo alone against no treatment.

Higher satisfaction did not equal greater objective improvement

Patient satisfaction was statistically higher on the side receiving the combination. However, the difference in total acne-scar reduction was not statistically significant, and ultrasound did not show a significant difference in scar-depth reduction between sides. Global improvement was rated the same in both groups. Rolling scars showed the best response on both sides.

These results should be described together. Satisfaction is important, but it can reflect texture, hydration, treatment expectations or subtle changes not captured by a scale. Conversely, a numerical measurement may miss a change meaningful to a patient. The study does not prove that Profhilo materially improves the scar release achieved by subcision.

Why the evidence remains preliminary

With only 12 participants, uncommon complications and smaller differences could easily be missed. Follow-up was short, and acne scars remodel over time. The photographic total score was created specifically for the study rather than being a widely established single outcome, which makes comparison with other trials difficult. Results may also vary with scar type and subcision technique.

The study cannot define an ideal dose, number of sessions, maintenance plan or long-term result. It also cannot show whether the combination is better value than subcision alone or another evidence-based scar treatment. A larger controlled trial with validated scar measures, longer follow-up and reporting by scar subtype would be needed before firm conclusions are justified.

Downtime and adverse effects come from both parts of treatment

Subcision commonly causes tenderness, swelling and bruising. Published reviews also describe infection, temporary lumps and altered pigmentation, with risk influenced by the instrument and technique. Profhilo injections can add stinging, redness, swelling, bruising, itching and temporary raised points. Combining procedures may increase treatment burden even when each individual effect is short-lived.

Increasing pain, spreading redness or heat, discharge, fever, a persistent or enlarging lump, blistering, marked colour change, eye pain or any visual symptom needs prompt clinical assessment. Sterile technique, authentic traceable products, written aftercare and access to timely review are essential. Treatment should not be timed immediately before an important event if bruising or swelling would be difficult to accommodate.

Suitability and alternatives require consultation

Assessment should map scar types, check for active acne or infection and review skin type, pigmentation tendency, healing history, medicines, allergies, previous procedures and relevant medical conditions. Pregnancy or breastfeeding, active inflammation and contraindications in the manufacturer’s instructions may mean Profhilo should not be used. Some people may need dermatology input before any cosmetic procedure.

Alternatives can include subcision alone, microneedling, resurfacing, other scar-directed procedures, camouflage or no treatment, depending on the scar pattern and priorities. No procedure can promise scar-free skin. GMC guidance requires clear discussion of evidence, risks, lower-risk alternatives, total costs and follow-up; this small trial supports further research, not a routine combination for everyone.

← Back to the journal

Personalised medical assessment

Questions about treatment?

Book a consultation to discuss your concerns, health and treatment options without pressure.

Free consultation – a £1 booking fee secures your appointment